Prior Authorization for Medication: Common Challenges and How to Overcome Them
- Jamie P
- Aug 12
- 7 min read
Discover the common challenges in prior authorization for medication and learn strategies to speed approvals, reduce denials, and ensure timely patient care.
Introduction: Why Prior Authorization Exists for Medication
Prior authorization (PA) for medication is a process in which healthcare providers must get approval from an insurance company before a prescription is covered. It’s meant to ensure medications are used appropriately, are medically necessary, and cost-effective.
While the intention behind prior authorization is to improve care and manage costs, the process can often be a source of frustration for patients and providers alike. Delays, denials, and complex requirements can prevent timely access to needed treatments.
Understanding the most common challenges — and how to navigate them — is the key to avoiding unnecessary delays and disruptions in care.
When Prior Authorization Is Required for Medication
Insurance companies don’t require PA for every prescription, but it’s more common for:
High-cost medications – especially brand-name drugs when generic alternatives are available.
Specialty drugs – such as biologics, injectable treatments, or drugs for rare diseases.
Medications with safety concerns – those requiring close monitoring.
Non-formulary drugs – drugs not listed on the insurance company’s approved list.
Step therapy cases – when insurers require trying less expensive treatments first.
Comprehensive Patient and Provider Checklist for Medication Prior Authorizations
One of the fastest ways to secure medication prior authorization is to prepare all required information and documentation before a request is submitted. Both patients and providers have important roles to play in ensuring that approvals come quickly and with minimal back-and-forth.
For Patients: How to Be Ready from the Start
Keep Your Insurance Information Handy: Your insurance card, member ID, and any secondary coverage details should be available before your provider begins the request.
Share a Complete Treatment History: List every medication you’ve tried for your condition, including dosages, duration, and the results. Include notes on any side effects or reasons you stopped a particular drug.
Provide Diagnostic Records: Bring copies of lab results, imaging, or specialist evaluations that confirm your diagnosis. These documents often make approval faster and easier.
Discuss Alternative Options: Ask your provider what backup medications or treatments might be possible in case your first-choice prescription is denied.
Track the Process: Write down when your provider submits the request and check back within 48 hours to confirm the insurer has received it.
For Providers: Best Practices Before Submission
Verify the Requirement: Use the insurance plan’s online portal to confirm that prior authorization is necessary for the prescribed drug.
Gather All Supporting Documentation: This includes clinical notes, diagnosis codes, and any lab results or past medication history. Having everything ready reduces the risk of follow-up delays.
Use the Preferred Submission Method: Electronic submissions are almost always faster than fax or phone requests. They also allow for easier tracking of the case status.
Assign a Dedicated Contact Person: A staff member — or virtual assistant — who handles prior authorizations daily can follow up quickly and consistently.
Shared Tips for Patients and Providers
Submit Early in the Week: Requests sent late on Fridays or before holidays can get stuck in processing queues.
Keep a Communication Log: Note dates, times, and names for every conversation with the insurer.
Respond Promptly: If the insurer requests additional information, respond within 24 hours to avoid unnecessary hold-ups.
By following these steps, both patients and providers can improve their chances of getting approval the first time, reducing the need for appeals and speeding up access to important medications.
The Prior Authorization Process for Medication
Step 1: Prescription and Verification
A provider prescribes a medication, and the pharmacy’s system flags it as requiring prior authorization based on the patient’s insurance plan.
Step 2: Submission of Request
The provider’s office submits the request, often through an online portal, fax, or phone, including medical documentation and justification.
Step 3: Clinical Review
The insurer’s clinical team compares the request to their guidelines to determine if it meets coverage criteria.
Step 4: Decision
Approval, denial, or a request for more information is issued — typically within a few days for standard requests, or within 24 hours for urgent cases.
Challenge #1: Incomplete or Incorrect Documentation
Why It Happens:
Missing diagnosis codes.
Lack of clinical notes showing medical necessity.
Failure to include prior treatment history.
How to Overcome It:
Use a standardized checklist before submission.
Include all relevant labs, imaging, and test results.
Double-check diagnosis and procedure codes for accuracy.
Explore: Your Guide to VA Success in 2024
Challenge #2: Delays in Communication
Why It Happens:
Requests for more information sent via fax or mail instead of digital channels.
Limited follow-up from provider offices due to heavy workloads.
How to Overcome It:
Use insurer’s electronic portals for faster updates.
Assign a dedicated staff member or virtual assistant to monitor PA status daily.
Respond to additional information requests within 24 hours.
Challenge #3: Denials Based on Medical Necessity
Why It Happens:
The medication is not on the formulary.
Insurer guidelines require step therapy first.
Lack of evidence that the drug is essential for the patient’s condition.
How to Overcome It:
Review insurer’s formulary before prescribing.
Document all failed treatments and adverse reactions.
Include peer-reviewed research or specialist notes when appropriate.
Challenge #4: Varying Requirements Across Insurance Plans
Why It Happens:
Each insurance plan may have unique forms, documentation requirements, and clinical criteria.
How to Overcome It:
Keep an internal database of plan-specific prior authorization rules.
Train staff regularly on the differences between insurers.
Use technology to track and automate PA submissions.
Challenge #5: High Administrative Burden on Providers
Why It Happens:
Prior authorization often requires significant time and staff resources, taking away from direct patient care.
How to Overcome It:
Outsource PA management to trained virtual assistants.
Integrate PA software tools into the EHR system.
Batch and prioritize requests daily to avoid backlogs.
Patient Strategies to Avoid Delays
Keep an updated list of medications and past treatments.
Ask your provider if your drug requires PA before leaving the appointment.
Stay in touch with both the provider and insurance company for updates.
Request temporary supply or samples if waiting on approval.
Provider Strategies to Improve Approval Rates
Create templates for commonly requested medications.
Train staff in insurer-specific requirements.
Submit requests as early in the day and week as possible.
Track denials to identify trends and address common issues.
Prior Authorization for Specialty and High-Cost Medications
Not all medications face the same level of scrutiny during the prior authorization process. Specialty drugs and high-cost medications often require extra documentation, more thorough reviews, and closer coordination between patients, providers, and insurers.
Examples of Specialty or High-Cost Medications
Cancer Therapies: Oral chemotherapy drugs, targeted biologics, and immunotherapy treatments.
Autoimmune Biologics: Injectable or infusion-based medications for conditions like rheumatoid arthritis, Crohn’s disease, or psoriasis.
Hepatitis C Treatments: Direct-acting antivirals that can cure the infection but come with a high price tag.
Rare Disease Therapies: Enzyme replacement treatments, gene therapies, and other orphan drugs.
Why These Drugs Require Stricter Review
Significant Financial Impact: Some of these drugs can cost thousands — or even tens of thousands — per month. Insurers want to ensure the treatment is absolutely necessary.
Specialized Monitoring Needs: Certain specialty drugs require regular lab work, imaging, or in-person monitoring to ensure patient safety and drug effectiveness.
Limited Distribution: Many specialty medications are only available through specific pharmacies, which adds another layer to the authorization process.
Additional Documentation Often Required
Specialist Notes: Reports from oncologists, rheumatologists, or other specialists confirming diagnosis and treatment necessity.
Test Results: Lab or imaging results that prove the patient meets clinical criteria.
Treatment History: Proof of previous failed or ineffective treatments.
Biomarker or Genetic Testing: Results required for drugs designed to target specific mutations or conditions.
Tips for Providers Handling Specialty Medication PAs
Prepare Documentation in Advance: Have all test results, clinical notes, and histories ready before initiating the request.
Use Specialty-Specific Forms: Many insurers offer tailored forms for certain medications that speed up review.
Follow Up Frequently: High-cost medication requests can take longer to process; check status every 24–48 hours for urgent cases.
Tips for Patients Awaiting Specialty Medication
Stay in Close Contact: Call your provider’s office and, if possible, your insurer regularly for updates.
Ask About Interim Solutions: See if your provider can provide a temporary supply, samples, or alternative treatments while waiting for approval.
Keep Everything Organized: Store copies of all submissions, approval letters, and denial notices to make appeals easier if needed.
The Importance of Thoroughness
Because specialty and high-cost medications are often used to treat serious or life-threatening conditions, delays can be more than just inconvenient — they can be dangerous. The more proactive both patients and providers are in gathering and submitting required information, the faster the approval process will be.
Appealing a Denied Prior Authorization for Medication
Steps to Take:
Review the denial letter for specific reasons.
Collect additional supporting evidence.
File the appeal within the insurer’s stated timeframe (often 30–60 days).
Request a peer-to-peer review if available.
Tips for Success:
Include detailed clinical notes and treatment history.
Attach published guidelines supporting the drug’s use.
Follow up regularly on appeal status.
Explore: Finding and Retaining Top Talent
The Role of Technology in Speeding Up Prior Authorizations
EHR Integration: Allows automatic population of forms with patient data.
PA Tracking Tools: Provide real-time updates and reminders.
Automation: Reduces manual data entry and improves accuracy.
Legislative and Policy Trends
State Reforms: Some states have passed laws limiting PA requirements for chronic medications.
Insurer Initiatives: Increasing use of “gold card” programs for providers with high approval rates.
Federal Proposals: CMS exploring automation and transparency standards for PA.
Final Thoughts
Prior authorization for medication can be a frustrating process, but it’s not insurmountable. By understanding the most common challenges — and proactively addressing them — patients and providers can work together to secure approvals faster, minimize treatment delays, and improve healthcare outcomes.
About OpsArmy
OpsArmy helps businesses and healthcare providers hire top 1% remote talent in operations, marketing, and sales from around the world. We make hiring simple, cost-effective, and fast so you can focus on growing your business.
Learn more at OpsArmy: https://operationsarmy.com
Comments