How to Get Prior Authorization for Prescription Drugs: Doctor, Pharmacy, and Plan Workflow
- Jamie P
- 3 days ago
- 7 min read
Prior authorization (PA) is the gate your health plan puts in front of certain prescriptions. It’s not the pharmacy saying “no”—it’s the insurer (or its pharmacy benefit manager, PBM) asking for proof that the medication meets coverage criteria before they’ll pay for it. When you know who does what, what documents are required, and where delays usually happen, you can turn a two-week slog into a quick approval.
This guide lays out the end-to-end workflow—from the moment your provider writes the prescription to the moment the pharmacy hands it over—plus checklists, scripts, and fast-track tactics that work in 2025. Use it whether you’re a patient, caregiver, clinic coordinator, or practice manager.
The Three Players—and What Each One Controls
Prescriber/Clinic: Chooses a medication, documents the medical need, and submits the PA. The clinic controls the quality and completeness of the request (which is the #1 driver of speed).
Pharmacy: Runs the insurance claim and sees the “PA required” reject, then alerts the clinic. The pharmacy controls dispensing logistics and re-billing after approval.
Health Plan / PBM: Reviews and decides (approve/deny/need more info). The plan controls policy criteria and decision timelines—and whether your request is handled as standard or urgent.
You (Patient/Caregiver): Provide insurance details and prior-medication history; keep everyone in sync; call the pharmacy to confirm re-billing once approved. You control momentum.
The End-to-End Timeline
Prescription written → Pharmacy runs claim (flags PA) → Clinic submits PA (ideally electronically) → Plan reviews (may ask for more info) → Decision → Pharmacy re-bills → Pickup or delivery.
Where time is lost: incomplete forms, missing labs or prior-med details, non-formulary requests without an exception rationale, or fax black holes. Where time is gained: electronic prior authorization (ePA) + complete documentation on the first pass + clear urgency statement (when appropriate).
Before the Visit: Prep That Prevents Delays
Bring a one-pager (digital or paper) your clinic can drop straight into the PA:
Insurance snapshot: Plan name, member ID, BIN/PCN/group (from your card).
Medication history: For each previous drug in the same class—name, dose, start/stop dates, and outcome (ineffective, side effects, contraindicated).
Recent labs or tests: Actual values and dates (lipids, A1c, TB test, LFTs, etc.—depends on the drug).
Allergy/contraindication list.
Preferred pharmacy info: Address/phone and whether you’re open to a specialty pharmacy if required.
Handing over this page saves your clinic 1–2 phone calls and gets you into the fast lane.
Explore: Decoding Medical Codes: The Beginner’s Guide To Healthcare Procedure Codes (ICD, CPT, HCPCS)
Make ePA Your Default and Fax Your Last Resort
Electronic prior authorization (ePA) lives inside many EHRs and connects to PBMs and plans. It guides staff through the exact fields plans require and usually supports attachments (chart notes, labs). Practical upsides:
Catches missing fields (ICD-10 diagnosis, dosing, quantity, prior meds) before submission
Routes to the right queue automatically
Posts status updates in the same system (no phone tag)
Returns approval letters clinicians can forward to the pharmacy immediately
If your clinic doesn’t have ePA, ask whether they use a plan portal instead—and offer your one-page med history and lab values to make the first pass complete. Fax only when there’s no other path or the portal is down.
What Goes Into a “First-Pass Approval” Packet
Medication details:
Drug name, strength, form, exact SIG, quantity, days’ supply
If the dose exceeds plan limits, include weight/BSA math or clinical rationale
Diagnosis & context:
Primary ICD-10 code and a short plain-English summary of severity, duration, and functional impact
Step-therapy grid:
For each alternative tried: name | dose | start–stop dates | outcome (ineffective, adverse event, contraindicated). If you’re skipping steps, cite why (e.g., contraindication or specialist recommendation).
Objective evidence:
Required labs with values and dates; imaging or standardized scores if relevant
Safety considerations:
Known contraindications, comorbidities, and why this drug is the safer/correct choice for this patient
Urgency (when appropriate):
One sentence clinicians can paste: “Expedited review requested due to [specific risk without treatment], supported by [lab/clinical fact].”
Direct callback:
A nurse or clinician line that reaches a human same day. Reviewers will call—answering fast prevents a multi-day loop.
Standard vs. Expedited: Which Clock Are You On?
Plans generally offer two timelines:
Standard: For routine requests where a short delay won’t cause significant harm.
Expedited/Urgent: When delay risks serious deterioration, hospitalization, or severe pain. The clinician includes a clear, one-sentence urgency statement tied to clinical facts.
Tip: Don’t mark everything urgent. Reserve expedited reviews for the cases that truly qualify—and make them impossible to ignore with crisp documentation.
Pharmacy Realities You Should Plan Around
Re-billing is not automatic. After approval, the pharmacy must re-run the claim. A quick phone call avoids another day lost to “we didn’t see the approval.”
Specialty drugs (biologics, injectables) may require a specific specialty pharmacy and cold-chain shipping. Someone may need to be home to sign.
Quantity limits can block a 90-day fill. If adherence will suffer, the prescriber can request an exception or write a two-step SIG (e.g., titration) with rationale.
Clean Hand-Offs: From Approval to Pickup
Once the plan approves:
Clinic forwards the approval letter (or portal screenshot) to your pharmacy and to you.
Pharmacy re-adjudicates the claim, confirms stock (or orders it), and schedules pickup/delivery.
You call to confirm it ran and ask about copay assistance (if the drug has a manufacturer program).
For specialty meds, ask the clinic whether they sent the prescription to the correct pharmacy listed on the approval.
Scripts You Can Copy
You → Clinic (Day 0–1): “Hi, the pharmacy says my prescription for [Drug] needs prior authorization. Can you submit it electronically and include my prior meds with doses/dates plus any required labs? I can email my med history today. Please call back with the reference number.”
Clinic → Plan (Expedited): “This is [Clinic] about member [ID] and [Drug]. We submitted electronically with chart notes and prior-med history. We request expedited review due to [specific risk]. Are any specific criteria still missing?”
You → Pharmacy (After Approval): “We have approval for [Drug]. Could you re-adjudicate today and let me know if it’s in stock or when shipment is scheduled?”
Specialty Medications: Extra Moving Pieces, Same Core Rules
Clinical criteria are stricter and almost always require prior-med failures or lab thresholds. Nail the step-therapy grid and attach the lab values on the first pass.
Limited-distribution drugs must go through a particular specialty pharmacy—sending to the wrong one adds days.
Bridge programs may help if you’re waiting on an appeal. Ask the clinic or manufacturer hub.
Common Reasons PAs Stall—and How to Unstick Them
“Tried alternatives” with no details:
Fix: Provide drug, dose, start–stop dates, outcome. If side effects, include exact symptoms.
Dose over plan limits:
Fix: Show weight/BSA math, titration schedule, or clinical guideline reference.
Non-formulary request:
Fix: Ask for a medical exception with contraindications or documented failures of preferred options.
Missing labs:
Fix: Upload values and dates. If pending, say exactly when they’ll be collected and whether therapy can safely begin.
Wrong channel (pharmacy vs. medical benefit):
Fix: If the drug is dispensed to the patient, it’s pharmacy benefit; if clinician-administered, it’s often medical. Route correctly.
Faxed into the void:
Fix: Switch to ePA or a plan portal; if fax is unavoidable, call to confirm receipt and include an attachments index on page one.
Appeals: Turning “No” Into “Yes”
A denial letter is a checklist: it names the criteria you didn’t meet.
Read the exact reason and paste it at the top of your appeal.
Target the gap—attach the missing labs, correct the dose, or add specialist notes.
Request expedited review if delay risks harm.
Ask for a peer-to-peer review and prepare a 90-second pitch that mirrors policy language.
Continuity of therapy exception: If stable on the med before a formulary change, request coverage to avoid harm from switching.
Plan Changes, New Year, New PBM: Don’t Lose Ground
At the start of a plan year, formularies and PBMs often change. Bring the new card to visits; your clinic may need a new portal or a fresh PA. If you were previously approved, ask about transition fills or a continuity-of-therapy exception while the new PA is processed.
Clinic SOP: A Reusable Blueprint
Intake:
One-page PA intake sheet: insurance details; prior-med grid; labs with dates; allergies; preferred pharmacy.
Submission:
ePA or portal only (fax = last resort).
Attach progress note, prior-med history, lab results, and urgency sentence (if applicable).
Include a direct callback to a nurse or prescriber.
Tracking:
Log submission date, reference number, and decision window (standard vs. expedited).
If the case is idle at 48–72 hours (expedited) or 7–10 days (standard), call with a specific question: “What exact criterion is missing?”
Post-approval:
Forward the letter to pharmacy and patient; confirm re-adjudication and stock/shipping.
If denied, launch a targeted appeal same day.
Patient & Caregiver Checklist
Bring a prior-med grid (drug, dose, dates, outcome)
Confirm insurance info (ID, BIN/PCN, group)
Ask clinic to use ePA and attach chart notes/labs
Get the reference number and decision window
Call the pharmacy after approval to re-bill and check stock
If denied, ask for the exact reason and a timeline for appeal
The Bottom Line
Getting prior authorization approved fast is less about arguing and more about sending the right evidence, in the right channel, the first time. Map your prescription to the plan’s rules, document prior therapies with doses and dates, include required labs, add a one-line urgency when appropriate, and keep a single point of contact reachable for follow-ups. Do that, and “PA pending” turns into “ready for pickup” far more often—and far faster.
About OpsArmy
OpsArmy helps businesses build reliable, cost-effective teams across admin, operations, finance, and growth—blending vetted global talent with clear SOPs and daily oversight to deliver results.
Learn more at https://operationsarmy.com
Comments