top of page
Search

The Small Business Owner’s Guide to Picking a Collection Agency

  • Writer: DM Monticello
    DM Monticello
  • Jul 3
  • 7 min read

Running a small business is tough enough without the headache of unpaid invoices. When clients or customers fail to pay, your cash flow suffers, and your team loses time chasing payments instead of growing the business. That’s why many entrepreneurs eventually turn to a collection agency for small business support.

But not all collection agencies are created equal—and choosing the wrong one can hurt your brand or cost you more than you recover. This guide will walk you through the benefits, risks, and best practices for hiring the right collection agency tailored to small businesses.

Why Small Businesses Use Collection Agencies

Cash Flow Challenges

For small businesses, every dollar counts. A few late or unpaid invoices can make it hard to cover payroll, buy inventory, or pay vendors. Unlike large corporations with internal finance teams, small businesses often don’t have the bandwidth to pursue overdue accounts.

That’s where a collection agency steps in—bringing structure, urgency, and legal understanding to help recover funds faster.

Discover ways to optimize your finances in How to Run a Small Business Profitably.

Limited Time and Staff

Owners and managers in small companies wear many hats—sales, customer service, admin, and more. Following up on overdue accounts often falls to the bottom of the to-do list. A professional collection agency can take over this task, allowing your team to focus on growth.

What a Collection Agency Does for Small Businesses

A collection agency becomes your partner in recovering past-due payments. Here’s how the process typically works:

  1. You send the agency a list of unpaid accounts, including invoices and contact info.

  2. The agency contacts the debtor through letters, emails, phone calls, or even text messages.

  3. They negotiate payment—either the full amount or a settlement.

  4. They report progress to you regularly and handle all legal compliance.

Some agencies only charge a fee if they collect money (contingency-based), while others may charge a flat fee per account.

Explore different pricing models in Cost-Effective Strategies for Business Growth.



Real-Life Examples: How Small Businesses Use Collection Agencies Successfully

Sometimes, the best way to understand the impact of a collection agency is to see it in action. Here are three real-life examples that show how small businesses have successfully used collections to regain control of their finances.

1. The Freelance Design Agency

Business type: Creative services firm in Austin, Texas Challenge: Three clients failed to pay after final project delivery, totaling $7,800 in unpaid invoices. Solution: The owner tried emailing and calling, but after 60 days with no resolution, she turned to a small-business-focused collections agency.

Outcome:

  • The agency recovered $5,000 within 45 days.

  • Two clients agreed to settle via monthly payments.

  • The agency avoided harsh language, preserving relationships.

Lesson: Early action and using a respectful agency helped the firm recover lost revenue without burning bridges.

See What Does a Sales Development Rep Do? for more on the value of professional outreach in business recovery.

2. The Medical Clinic

Business type: Family practice in Upstate New York Challenge: Patients frequently left small co-pays and balances unpaid, adding up to $15,000 in outstanding accounts. Solution: The clinic partnered with a local collections agency familiar with HIPAA and medical debt.

Outcome:

  • The agency recovered $10,500 within three months.

  • They provided regular reports to the clinic.

  • Clear scripts and guidelines ensured patients were treated respectfully.

Lesson: Industry-specific collections partners can navigate sensitive topics like healthcare bills while staying compliant.

Check out Healthcare Virtual Assistants to learn how clinics can use outsourced help effectively.

3. The E-Commerce Brand

Business type: Online apparel shop selling nationwide Challenge: High-volume, low-dollar orders often went unpaid due to chargebacks or failed layaway plans. Solution: After months of internal attempts, the business outsourced to a collection agency with digital tracking and automated systems.

Outcome:

  • The agency recovered over $8,000 from 200+ micro accounts.

  • The e-commerce business set stricter pre-payment policies.

  • The agency’s online portal allowed the team to track recoveries in real time.

Lesson: Even small amounts add up. Partnering with a tech-savvy agency helped the business reclaim revenue at scale.

Learn how to organize tech systems in How to Achieve Efficient Back Office Operations.



Benefits of Using a Collection Agency

Hiring a collection agency may seem like a big step, especially for a small business. But when done correctly, it comes with several advantages:

1. Improves Working Capital

Recovering unpaid debts gives your business more liquidity to invest in marketing, operations, or staffing. It helps reduce reliance on loans or credit lines, giving you more financial control.

2. Saves Time and Resources

Instead of spending hours sending follow-ups, your team can focus on high-value tasks like sales or customer service. The agency handles everything from outreach to documentation.

For time-saving tactics, check out How to Automate Back-Office Operations.

3. Protects Client Relationships (When Done Right)

A professional, ethical agency will use firm but respectful communication. This allows you to recover funds without burning bridges—critical for small businesses that rely on referrals and repeat clients.

See How to Build Long-Term Customer Loyalty for strategies to maintain good relationships.

How to Know When It’s Time to Hire an Agency

Wondering if it’s too early—or too late—to bring in a collection agency? Here are signs it’s time:

  • The invoice is more than 60–90 days past due

  • You’ve made 2–3 attempts to collect with no response

  • The account is large enough to justify outside help (e.g., $500+)

  • Your team is spending too much time chasing late payments

Early action often leads to higher recovery rates. Waiting too long can make debts harder to collect.



How to Choose the Right Agency for a Small Business

Not every collection agency is a good fit for a small business. Here’s how to make sure you choose a trustworthy and effective partner:

1. Look for Industry Experience

An agency that has worked with small businesses—or within your specific industry—will understand your unique challenges. For example:

  • Medical practices need agencies familiar with HIPAA rules.

  • Retailers need a firm grasp of consumer payment patterns.

  • Service providers need collectors who know how to interpret contracts and hourly billing.

2. Prioritize Clear, Fair Pricing

Small businesses can’t afford surprise fees. Ask for:

  • A transparent commission rate (typically 20–40%)

  • Information on flat fees, if applicable

  • Any extra charges for legal action, credit reporting, or account setup

Always get pricing in writing before committing.

Explore additional pricing strategies in Guide to Small Business Invoicing.

3. Check for Compliance and Licensing

Make sure your agency:

  • Is licensed in your state (especially important in states like New York and California)

  • Follows the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA)

  • Maintains bonding and insurance

You want an agency that protects your brand, not one that risks lawsuits or negative publicity.

See How to Manage Compliance for Global Teams for broader compliance practices.

4. Review Their Communication Practices

Ask:

  • How often will they update you?

  • What methods do they use to contact debtors?

  • Will they treat your clients with professionalism?

Agencies that use harassment or deception can hurt your brand—even if they collect the debt.

Learn to protect your brand image in How to Choose a Digital Marketing Agency.

Red Flags to Avoid

Stay away from agencies that:

  • Can’t clearly explain their fee structure

  • Use threatening or unethical language

  • Refuse to provide references or reviews

  • Have unresolved complaints with the Better Business Bureau

You want a partner that values long-term success—not just a quick buck.

How to Prepare Before Sending Accounts to Collections

1. Organize Your Records

Before sending accounts to a collection agency, gather:

  • The original contract or purchase order

  • All invoices and payment records

  • Any email or written communication with the client

  • Notes from calls or internal follow-ups

This information gives the agency the best chance of recovering your funds.

For best practices on records, check out How to Streamline Back-Office Operations.

2. Set an Escalation Policy

Have a system in place for when to escalate an account. For example:

  • 0–30 days: internal reminder

  • 31–60 days: follow-up call

  • 61–90 days: final notice

  • 91+ days: send to collections

This prevents missed opportunities and ensures fairness across all accounts.

3. Communicate Clearly With the Client

Before handing off an account, send a final notice such as:

"If payment is not received within 7 business days, this account will be referred to a licensed collections agency."

Sometimes, that last warning is enough to prompt a response.

Alternatives to Consider Before Hiring an Agency

1. Offer Flexible Payment Options

Clients may be more likely to pay if you allow split payments or extend terms.

2. Use a Virtual Assistant for Follow-Ups

A virtual assistant can send automated reminders and escalate accounts internally—freeing your team to focus on growth.

Read more in Virtual Assistant Services for Small Businesses.

3. Send Final Warning Letters

Sometimes, a formal letter stating your intent to escalate the debt can nudge the client to pay before you involve a third party.

Final Tips for Small Business Owners

  • Choose an agency that aligns with your values and brand

  • Get everything in writing, including fees and expectations

  • Regularly review performance and adjust your process as needed

  • Protect your client relationships and legal standing

A collection agency for small business can be a powerful tool—but only if it’s the right fit. With the right partner and preparation, you can recover revenue, strengthen your financial position, and grow with confidence.



OpsArmy: Your Partner in Smarter Business Operations

OpsArmy is building AI-native back office operations as a service (OaaS). We help businesses run their day-to-day operations with AI-augmented teams, delivering outcomes across sales, admin, finance, and hiring. In a world where every team is expected to do more with less, OpsArmy provides fully managed “Ops Pods” that blend deep knowledge experts, structured playbooks, and AI copilots. Think of us as your operational infrastructure: running faster, leaner, and smarter business execution. Visit operationsarmy.com to learn more.



Sources





 
 
 

Commentaires

bottom of page